Supreme Court vs. Family Court: Why Divorce Under Article 142 is Completely Different & Much Faster
(Explained in light of latest Supreme Court judgments – 2024–2025) | Purely educational content | Not legal advice
The Supreme Court has once again clarified a very important distinction that every person stuck in a broken marriage must know:
Family Court → Bound by “fault” rules of Hindu Marriage Act (cruelty, desertion, adultery, etc.) Supreme Court (under Article 142) → Can ignore all faults and simply dissolve a dead marriage to do complete justice
This principle has been repeatedly laid down in 2024–2025 judgments including Rinku Baheti vs. Sandesh Sharda (Dec 2024) and earlier in Shilpa Sailesh vs. Varun Sreenivasan (2023).
Key Differences – Supreme Court vs. Family Court
| Point | Family Court / High Court (Hindu Marriage Act) | Supreme Court (Article 142 Route) |
|---|---|---|
| Must prove “fault” (cruelty, desertion, etc.)? | YES – Mandatory | NO – Not required |
| Lengthy evidence & cross-examination? | YES – Full trial | NO – Court takes holistic view |
| Can grant divorce if both parties do not agree? | NO (except on proven grounds) | YES – Even if one party opposes |
| Looks into who is right/wrong? | YES – Detailed findings on allegations | NO – Court does NOT decide who is at fault |
| Time taken | 3–10 years | 3–12 months (often faster in Transfer Petitions) |
| Can dissolve marriage which is simply “dead”? | NO – Only if statutory ground is proved | YES – If marriage has irretrievably broken down |
| Role of the Court | Judge of facts & law | Problem-solver & dispenser of complete justice |
When Does the Supreme Court Use Article 142 for Divorce?
Only when the Court is fully satisfied that:
- The marriage has completely failed
- There is zero chance of reconciliation
- Forcing the parties to remain married is meaningless and oppressive
- No useful purpose will be served by keeping the legal tie alive
The Court acts as a problem-solver, not as a trial court finding faults.
Practical Advantages of Article 142 Route (2025 Scenario)
- You don’t have to prove cruelty, adultery, or desertion with evidence.
- No need for lengthy cross-examination of witnesses.
- Even if the other spouse is bitterly opposing divorce, the Supreme Court can still dissolve the marriage.
- Ideal for childless couples or couples separated for 7–15+ years.
- Can be prayed for in Transfer Petitions, SLPs, or even directly in some cases.
FAQ – Article 142 Divorce in Supreme Court (2025)
Can I directly file for divorce under Article 142 in Supreme Court?
Usually no. It is tagged with a pending Transfer Petition, SLP, or Appeal. But strong cases can be converted into Article 142 petitions.
My spouse is opposing divorce. Will Article 142 still help?
Yes. Recent 2024–2025 orders show Supreme Court grants divorce despite strong opposition when marriage is dead.
Do we still have to pay permanent alimony?
Yes. Supreme Court almost always settles full & final alimony/stridhan in the same order.
Is there any cooling-off period like in mutual consent divorce?
No. Supreme Court can waive the 6–18 month cooling period under Article 142.
What if there are children?
Possible, but harder. Court gives top priority to child welfare and custody. Childless cases are dissolved fastest.
How to convince the Supreme Court that marriage is irretrievably broken?
File detailed affidavit showing: long separation, failed mediation, no cohabitation, no intimacy, bitterness, etc.
Can this be done in a Transfer Petition itself?
Yes! Hundreds of marriages are being dissolved every year in Transfer Petitions without transferring the case anywhere.
How fast can it happen?
Genuine cases with good drafting → 3–9 months from filing to final divorce decree.
Will the Supreme Court record findings on who was cruel?
No. The Court deliberately avoids fault-finding and simply declares the marriage dissolved.
Is this judgment ratio applicable only to Hindus?
No. Article 142 applies to all personal laws — Hindu, Muslim (extra-judicial), Christian, Special Marriage Act, etc.
Need urgent dissolution of a dead marriage through Article 142? Contact Legal Light Consulting – LLC Lawyers We specialise in:
- Transfer Petitions + Article 142 divorce prayers
- One-time settlement of alimony & stridhan
- Urgent listing before appropriate Bench
Same-day drafting | Pan-India service | Proven track record in 2024–2025 cases
✆ WhatsApp/Call: +91 9999641341
